During a recent address at Trinity College in Ireland, Mark Carney reflected on a quote from Edmund Burke, the notable 18th-century politician and thinker, who was also a graduate of the institution. Burke described society as a collaboration among the living, the deceased, and those who have not yet come into existence.
Following his prepared speech, Carney was joined on stage by Alex White, a former Irish cabinet minister. White recalled Carney’s pivotal “tragedy of the horizon” speech delivered while he served as governor of the Bank of England, noting that Burke’s words were particularly relevant in the context of climate change and its effects on future generations.
Carney agreed with White’s perspective, highlighting a political challenge he previously articulated: short-term incentives often hinder climate action.
“The issue with climate and many other public policy matters,” Carney stated, “[is] that the right actions, in line with Burke’s philosophy … the benefits or validation of those actions lie beyond your political tenure, potentially even beyond your electoral term, often extending beyond your career. This holds true even for those who achieve great success.”
History has demonstrated that it is often too easy for political figures (and consequently, their constituents) to delay necessary actions against climate change.
-
Youth, advocacy groups sue Carney government over climate rollbacks
-
Ex-member of top climate body says Alberta pipeline deal is not compatible with net-zero
-
Guilbeault says Canada ‘backsliding’ on climate action as he resigns as MP
Just two days after Carney’s address at Trinity College, Ecojustice filed an application in Federal Court on behalf of several young environmental activists and two ecological organizations, asserting that the Carney government’s climate policies are now inconsistent with federal legislation.
“When political leaders claim to be dedicated to climate action while simultaneously dismantling the necessary policies to achieve it, young people take notice because we are the ones who will endure the consequences,” stated 19-year-old Sophia Mathur at a press conference in Ottawa this week.
While Mathur and her co-applicants are focused on long-term implications, their lawsuit brings up a significant near-term issue for the Carney administration.
A test of net-zero accountability
This legal action revolves around the Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act, a piece of legislation introduced by the Liberal government under Justin Trudeau and passed by Parliament in 2021. Modeled after similar laws in other regions, this act mandates that the federal government establish emissions reduction targets, create plans to meet those targets, and routinely update the nation on its progress.
The initial plan was released in 2022, with the objective of reducing emissions by 40% from 2005 levels by 2030. An assessment by the Canadian Climate Institute labeled this plan as “credible.”
However, as the applicants point out in their filing, significant changes have been made to federal climate policies since then, including the complete repeal of the consumer carbon tax and adjustments to several other initiatives. A progress report issued by the Carney government in 2025 projected a national emissions reduction of 28% by 2030. While this would be an accomplishment compared to Canada’s historical record of emission reductions, it still falls short of the official target.
Given that the 2022 plan is no longer valid, the applicants argue that the government must be required to develop a new strategy that can meet Canada’s 2030 objectives (which the Carney administration continues to assert it supports).
“We’re requesting a plan that aims to meet the target, not one destined to fail,” stated Charlie Hatt from Ecojustice during the news conference.
(A separate legal challenge, initiated several years ago based on Charter rights, is still progressing through the judicial system.)
It remains unclear how the Carney government will react to the application, either in a legal capacity or in terms of policy. However, in a recent conversation with the Narwhal, former environment minister Steven Guilbeault speculated that a legal challenge could arise and suggested that the administration might consider repealing the accountability law.
Should the Carney government take such a step, it would likely face backlash. However, revoking the law would also relieve future administrations from the accountability the legislation was designed to enforce. Current government ministers might contend that the Trudeau administration left them and Canadian climate policy in a difficult situation, but they may still prefer to leave behind a law that a future Conservative administration would have to navigate.
When introducing the net-zero accountability act in November 2020, Jonathan Wilkinson expressed hope that it would “depoliticize climate action” at the national level. Although this may have been overly optimistic, the former environment minister also contended that the bill would “ensure that Canada never has a government like that of Stephen Harper, which set an emissions reduction target but failed to present a viable plan to achieve it.”
In defense of Harper, establishing a target without an accompanying plan was a bipartisan practice adhered to by various prime ministers over many years.
More neutrally, the Canadian Climate Institute proposed in a report released in June 2020 that, “Climate accountability frameworks can assist in bridging the divide between medium- and long-term goals and the policy actions needed to achieve them.”
This might be seen as connecting the horizon with the political cycle.
Carney’s perspective on climate policy
Despite facing criticism for his adjustments to federal climate policy, Carney continues to address climate change as a pressing issue. He does not present himself as a politician who feels the need to trivialize the matter.
“Climate change is no longer a mere warning. It is a reality,” he stated at Trinity College.
He informed his audience that last year in Canada, “forests equivalent to the size of Ireland were consumed by fire due to heat and drought.”
When his Irish interviewer later brought up the topic of climate, Carney reiterated his previous stance, as a central banker, that improved information and transparency could enable markets to better prepare for climate change and shifts in climate policy. He acknowledged that this goal has not yet been fully achieved, partly due to emerging immediate concerns.
“The reduction in climate action stems from the affordability crisis that families are currently experiencing for various reasons,” Carney remarked, seemingly addressing a global audience rather than specifically referring to Canada. “This implies that we must adapt our approaches.”
Carney indicated that one of his government’s priorities was “identifying opportunities for significant climate gains by reducing emissions in ways that enhance our businesses’ competitiveness while ensuring that Canadian families are not financially burdened.”
Specifically, Carney highlighted the intention to expand Canada’s electricity grid and utilize the “government balance sheet” to distribute the costs associated with this initiative.
Clean electricity could indeed become the cornerstone of Canada’s climate strategy. Moreover, federal climate policy was destined to evolve regardless of who held the prime ministerial office after last year’s election.
The pressing question now is whether the Carney government can guide Canada toward a credible path to net-zero while also preserving the law intended to ensure accountability for all governments through to 2050.


