With increasing pressure from the Trump administration, Ottawa is being urged to enhance its examination of imports associated with forced labour. In response, Canadian human rights attorneys are directing their attention towards companies in the United States.
The Canadian Lawyers for International Human Rights (CLAIHR) has lodged a formal complaint with the Competition Bureau against four companies accused of utilizing forced labour in Alabama.
Filed in May, the complaint asserts that these companies have employed incarcerated individuals through Alabama’s prison labour system, claiming that the state’s work release programs constitute forced labour according to Canadian legislation.
“This situation resembles modern-day slavery,” stated James Yap, president of CLAIHR, referencing a two-year investigation by The Associated Press alongside various documentaries, reports, and lawsuits where current and former inmates allege they are compelled to work for minimal pay, face penalties for refusing work, or are dismissed for uncontrollable reasons.
Inmates have also claimed that their parole applications were denied if they chose not to work.
“Such conditions equate to coercion that essentially forces individuals into work release positions and compels them to stay,” commented Meredith Stewart, litigation director at Jobs to Move America, speaking to CBC News. The organization initiated a lawsuit regarding the entry of prison labour products into California.
According to Stewart, Jobs to Move America has extensively interacted with inmates in Alabama and conducted surveys.
Alabama officials insist that the program is voluntary and aids incarcerated individuals in preparing for their return to society. CBC News reached out to Alabama Corrections for a statement but did not receive a reply by the deadline.
Why File with the Competition Bureau?
The complaint targets four organizations: lumber manufacturer Canfor, automobile producers Hyundai Canada and Kia Canada, and door manufacturer Masonite International. Utilizing information from The Associated Press investigation and documentation from the Alabama Department of Corrections, it claims these businesses either directly or through their suppliers, employed prison labour and provided misleading statements in their annual reports under Canada’s Supply Chains Act.
This legislation mandates that large corporations disclose how they are preventing forced labour from infiltrating their supply chains, but Yap argues that these reports lack rigorous examination.
In a statement to CBC News, a representative from Public Safety Canada acknowledged that the law emphasizes transparency and reporting.
“The reporting exercise aims to foster transparency, not to penalize entities for identifying risks in their operations and supply chains,” the spokesperson remarked.
Although it is illegal to import items produced with forced labour, critics assert that enforcement is insufficient. Yap states that this complaint represents his group’s effort to ensure accountability.
“Making declarations that there is no forced labour within their supply chains, while they are, in fact, associated with forced prison labour in Alabama, constitutes a breach of competition law,” he explained.
In their comments to CBC News, both Hyundai and Kia asserted their compliance with applicable laws and expect the same from their suppliers. Hyundai further stated that its supplier code of conduct explicitly prohibits any use of forced labour throughout the production process.
Neither company addressed the assertion that the Alabama work-release program constitutes forced labour.
“Previously, certain U.S. mills took part in state-organized work release programs,” Canfor stated. “These initiatives were voluntary, compensated, and aimed primarily at aiding individuals’ reintegration into the community post-release. We no longer engage in these community programs.”
Additionally, Owens Corning, which acquired Masonite International in 2024, acknowledged in its statement to CBC News and in its modern slavery report that it utilized prison labour at one of its facilities, which resulted in products entering Canada.
Owens Corning mentioned that it ceased using the program following the acquisition, ensured standard wages were paid, and thoroughly reviewed its supplier list to confirm compliance.
However, Yap believes the company should be held responsible for the misleading statements made under Masonite’s prior reporting. His organization is urging the competition commissioner to investigate all four companies and, should the complaint be validated, impose fines and require them to provide clarifications.
“Canada has a responsibility not to be complicit in or support the usage of forced labour globally by allowing the importation of and permitting Canadian consumers to purchase products linked to forced labour,” he stated.
Support for the complaint comes from former Liberal MP John McKay and Sen. Julie Miville-Dechêne, who introduced the Fighting Against Forced Labour and Child Labour in Supply Chains Act. In a letter accompanying the submission, they expressed hope that the annual reports mandated by their bill — which became law in 2023 — could lead to greater accountability.
“These reports also serve as valuable information sources for various stakeholders, including the media and NGOs dedicated to combating modern slavery, as well as banks and investors who refer to these reports to assess investment risks,” they stated.
The Competition Bureau did not confirm whether it has ever investigated any modern slavery reports from companies, citing confidentiality surrounding its investigations.
Calls for ‘Principled Enforcement’
In April, the University of Toronto’s international human rights program filed a complaint with the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), urging it to investigate specific goods entering Canada that were partially produced using Alabama prison labour. Researchers examined records from the Alabama Department of Corrections and matched them with suppliers bringing goods into the country.
“This highlights the necessity for consistent, principled, and good faith enforcement,” remarked Nabila Khan, a human rights lawyer and research associate with the program.
Recently, the federal Liberal government has faced backlash for initially evading inquiries regarding forced labour in China, following the prime minister’s agreement to permit a limited number of Chinese electric vehicle imports into Canada at a reduced tariff rate.
“Discourse surrounding forced labour and prison labour often concentrates on global supply chains in the Global South — factories in Southeast Asia or agricultural sectors in Latin America. However, the utilization of prison labour in the U.S., which frequently occurs under highly coercive and exploitative conditions, receives significantly less attention,” Khan noted.
The CBSA informed CBC News that it is reviewing the raised concerns but refrained from specifying if it is investigating any particular company “to protect the integrity of the investigative process.”
Khan also recognizes that this is a delicate moment for Canada to enforce restrictions on imports from the U.S., given the ongoing tense discussions regarding the renewal of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement. The U.S. has pointed out Canada’s alleged leniency in enforcing forced labour laws as a trade friction point and has threatened to impose a 10 percent tariff on non-CUSMA compliant imports as a result.
-
Ottawa aims to strengthen ban on imports produced with forced labour following U.S. tariff threat
-
Trump threatens refusal to renew trade agreement with Canada and Mexico
Recently, the federal government introduced a new bill aimed at tightening its oversight of imports. If approved, it will authorize the foreign affairs minister to compile a list of goods and regions deemed to be at high risk for forced labour usage. Officials did not specify which regions may be affected, but both Khan and Yap have called for adherence to consistent and equitable practices.
“This is essentially a test of whether Canada’s prohibitions against forced labour and prison labour are enforceable or if political considerations or proximity will overshadow our legal and human rights obligations,” Khan concluded.

